Apology matters when crisis go viral

The D&G case in 2018 was discussed thoroughly in two blogs here — how it made Chinese outraged and started boycotting D&G, and what we can learn from this typical example of “NOT to do” in crisis communication, etc. Today let’s look into this case again within perspectives of social media and transcultural communication.

The snowball effect of social media

With its establishment in 1985, the first two decades of D&G were typically the traditional media era. But nowadays situations are more complicated with social media’s tremendous growth, as stated by a Fastcompany piece: “The D&G ad, which could have been a small gaffe in the past, has snowballed into a viral scandal that has reverberated around the world.”

How did social media make this even bigger than it could have been in the era of traditional media? Leave the traditional media aside, we may get some clues of how social media made it viral by reviewing the timeline of the crisis.

1.On Nov 18, 2018, D&G released the racist advertising campaign via its official Weibo account. It immediately rocked among Chinese and the anger has spread so quickly that D&G had to take down the videos within 24 hours.

2. On Nov 19, Diet Prada, an Instagram account that has become an industry watchdog, reposted the offensive videos.

3. On Nov 20, some horrifying messages sent by Stefano Gabbana’s personal Instagram account was leaked.

Source: Instagram

4. On Nov 21, D&G was compelled by the Shanghai government to cancel “The Great Show” just hours before it is scheduled to take place, upon continuous withdraw of Chinese celebrities/models from participating it.

5. On Nov 23, D&G published an apology video featured with its two founders on Weibo.

According to Social mediated crisis communication (SCCT), there are three types of publics that interact with an organization during a crisis via social media: 1) influential social media creators who create crisis information, 2) social media followers who consume the influential social media creators’ crisis information, and 3) social media inactive who consume influential social media creators’ crisis information indirectly through offline word-of-mouth communication and/or traditional media (Liu, Austin, & Jin, 2011). Applied the theory to this crisis, we can identify three types of public on social media.

Firstly, D&G itself meets the standards of “influential social media creators” who provoked the crisis by launching a controversial campaign. Secondly, other influencers such as Diet Prada and Chinese celebrities further spread the information to attract public attention, resulting in huge online buzz among their followers. Moreover, the followers, in turn, affected the magnitude of crisis by spreading the information offline, resulting in a viral scandal.

Why apology matters?

Generally speaking, apology is an effective strategy in crisis when the organization was held to be fully responsible. Unfortunately, it took D&G a whole week to deliver their apology, which made the situation from bad to worse. But why apology matters even more in this case?

From the transcultural perspective, individualistic and collectivistic societies hold different views toward an apology. As stated by Sung and Hwang (2014), an apology conveys admission of fault and personal responsibility in individualistic cultures, so organizations are often reluctant to apologize for fear of legal responsibilities. While in collectivistic cultures, people take apologies as “recognition of a burden suffered by the target” (Oki, 1993), so a public apology from an organization conveys a concern for the other party and does not necessarily have legal implications. This may explain a bit why the apology from D&G came so late and the Chinese took the delay as a bigger offense.

Moreover, in collectivistic cultures such as China, apologizing publicly can be a challenge for individuals and organizations because people value their “face” very much, and they are afraid of “losing face” by making a public apology. While this is exactly why apology during a crisis can lead to positive outcomes – because this action usually exceeds stakeholders’ expectations.

All in all, it’s time for brands to catch up, given that the rising of global markets and social media have changed the rules of crisis communication.

About the author: Chanchan Zhang is a Master student at the Department of Communication Science of the University of Amsterdam, the track she’s pursuing is Corporate Communication. She holds a degree in Psychology and has several years of experience working in advertising agency.

Reference

B. F. Liu, L. Austin, Y. Jin, (2011). How publics respond to crisis communication strategies: The interplay of information form and source, Public Relations Review, Volume 37, 345-353, ISSN 0363-8111, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pubrev.2011.08.004.

Minjung Sung, Jang-Sun Hwang, (2014). Who drives a crisis? The diffusion of an issue through social networks, Computers in Human Behavior, Volume 36, 246-257, ISSN 0747-5632, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2014.03.063.            

Oki, H. (1993). The use of apology-gratitude expressions in dialects. Nihongogaku, 12(11), 39–47.

Beyond the strike

During the Great Recession outbreak in 2007 and economic uncertainty that followed, the US automotive workers accepted concessions to allow GM (General Motors) as well as other auto companies to recover.

Though GM has since returned to profitability, worker compensation has remained stagnant, and the company continues to shut down US facilities and move some jobs abroad. Representatives for GM and UAW (United Auto Workers union) have been meeting for contract negotiations since this July to hammer out details on concerned issues. The union was also pushing for GM to reconsider the proposed closures of four facilities. Unfortunately, the negotiation failed to reach any agreements and thus resulted in a massive strike.

On September 16th, nearly 50,000 GM workers walked out on a strike demanding higher wages, more generous health care benefits and more job security.

The month-long strike is still going on with more stakeholders’ involvement.

Source: Getty Images

A good chance to observe interplay among stakeholders

On the same day that strike debuted, president Trump spoked to media that “federal mediation is always possible” between GM and the UAW. Apparently, the president needs the support from workers for the upcoming presidential election, thus he has a big interest in seeing GM reopen its closed plants. The actions from political parties didn’t come singly but in pairs. During the following week, several Democratic senators appeared in the strike to support striking workers. 

Source: New York Times

Besides UAW, IBT (International Brotherhood of Teamsters), a labor union in the United States and Canada, decided to stop delivering GM cars during the strike to show their supportiveness.

On September 17th, GM stopped providing health insurance to striking workers. This reaction was intended to force the labor union to give up, however, it didn’t work out. On September 26th, it was announced that GM would start to pay health insurance again to workers on strike.

By then the strike has shut down production at more than 30 GM factories and it cost GM approximately $90m each day, not to mention its suppliers which were disrupted by the strike. Also, the strike has extended to some other automakers such as Ford and Chrysler in October.

This strike was an event involving multiple parties (stakeholders) to interplay rather than a single case within one company and its employees, which makes it a good chance for PRps to observe different stakeholders’ reactions and the consequences. Furthermore, as we can see in most media coverage, the media tended to reframe the strike in a bigger picture. They are more concerned with the story behind as well as its influence on the auto industry and overall economy in the US.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free